Here’s How To Get The Most Out Of Feedback, Even When Poorly Delivered

Here’s How To Get The Most Out Of Feedback, Even When Poorly Delivered

This post first appeared on Forbes.com

We’re repeatedly told that feedback is a gift. Feedback is data that lets us know how our performance is being received and perceived. At its best, feedback helps us learn: it provides information about whether our impact matches our intentions, guidance on how we might do something differently and perhaps better, and clarity about whether we are meeting expectations. Just as top athletes need a coach’s guidance to improve, high performers benefit from quality feedback, both in terms of performance and engagement.

At the same time, research has demonstrated that the way many organizations do feedback—through infrequent, formal, top-down reviews that focus on correction—is not particularly effective. Unsurprisingly, feedback is often riddled with bias. When poorly delivered, it can also trigger anxiety and other emotions that interfere with learning, and it tends to focus on trying to correct deficits rather than build on strengths.

Over fifteen years of coaching and conducting feedback training at law firms, tech companies and foundations, I have observed their earnest efforts to create a more open and constructive feedback culture. Despite skill-building workshops and encouraging employees to have thoughtful, direct, open conversations, chronic overwork and time shortage, power dynamics, and interpersonal hangups stubbornly resist. In our workshops, people report that they hate giving feedback and thus they don’t do it often enough while at the same time saying that they wish they received more actionable feedback. Those who have been fortunate enough to receive clear, helpful feedback remember and cherish those experiences and are eternally grateful to people who took the time to give this valuable gift, but these stories are the minority. More often we hear about harshly delivered criticism, vague guidance and glib platitudes that do little to help them improve.

The truth is that most managers don’t get adequate feedback training, or if they do, they don’t follow best practices. At the same time, high performers and those who want to grow in their careers crave more high-quality feedback. Since they cannot count on others to take initiative or to be skilled when they do offer feedback, I am convinced that individuals seeking to learn and grow need to equip themselves with the tools that will empower them to mine for the gold in whatever feedback comes their way.

There is almost always something to learn from even the most ill-delivered feedback. It might shed light on an unintended impact you are having and allow you to make an adjustment. But even if not, you can learn a lot about the other person—their needs and expectations, their values, assumptions and interpretations—which enables you to be more intentional about your own behavior. The key is to operate from curiosity rather than defense, let them know that you want to improve and request specifics. Here are some common situations and potential responses:

The Vague Critique—“Your email tone is a little off” or “Work on your client presence” let you know that something is off, but not how to act on it. Even though the feedback may sting and you may feel embarrassed, ask for specific examples and guidance.

  • “Thanks for letting me know. I definitely want to strike the right tone. Was I overly terse? What tone are you aiming for—do you have an example?”
  • “I appreciate the feedback, and I am aware that client presence is important. On the most recent call, what did you notice that I might do differently?

The Outburst—“This project is completely off-track!” When someone loses their cool, feedback is often unskilled, laden with negative emotion and unactionable. Your own emotions—embarrassment, shame or anger—may rise up. Take a breath and acknowledge the feedback, which buys you some time and helps the other person feel heard. Then ask a clarifying question.

  • “Okay, you said the project is off-track. Where do you see we got off-course? What elements are most critical to getting back on track?”
  • “I hear that you are very concerned about the project. Let’s walk through the status and see what is needed.”

The Complaint—”I’m carrying this whole project.” or “I’m not getting the support I need.” This could be indirect feedback for you or it could be a request for help.

  • “I’m sorry to hear that there’s so much on your shoulders. Let’s talk about your expectations and where I may have been falling short, as well as what other resources are available.”
  • “What do you need? How can I help?”

The Ghost—Sometimes, a colleague just stops giving you work or communicating about a project or workstream and you wonder if you did something wrong. Unlike dating, in the workplace you should ask.

  • You can ask that person directly: “I noticed that I’m no longer on the distribution for x project. I enjoyed it and am available if you need me, but I’m also wondering if you have any feedback for me on my earlier work—what I did well and what I need to improve?”
  • Or you can ask your manager or assignment coordinator: “I’d like to have the opportunity to work again with Sunita. Do you know if she was satisfied with my performance on the last transaction? I would welcome feedback on how to improve.”

The Glib Praise—“Great job!” or “Keep up the good work!” feels nice in the moment, but it’s hardly actionable. Say thank you, but don’t let it end there. Even though you might feel a bit weird about asking someone to elaborate on a compliment, dig a little deeper.

  • “Thanks, Sandra. If you have a minute, can you help me identify what specifically I did that I should keep doing?”
  • “Thank you for letting me know. This was my first time and I wasn’t clear on the expectations. Could you take a minute to walk me through one or two things I did well and what I could improve?”

In all likelihood initiating these conversations will feel a bit awkward at first. But awkwardness won’t kill you. Remember that when you ask questions about how you can improve, you are signaling your interest in growing and developing, which most managers and colleagues will receive favorably. Curiosity and a determination to improve is at the heart of innovation and key to adapting and succeeding in the modern professional world.