sail boats racing

Leadership: Navigating Conditions Beyond Your Control

This post first appeared on Forbes.com

“In charge” does not mean “in control.” It doesn’t take long as a leader to realize that authority only gets you so far. Even if you have a large span of control to make strategic decisions and direct resources, any decision you make must be executed by others, requiring that you influence, motivate, or inspire them to follow your direction. Moreover, you can’t control market conditions, competitors, or customer behavior, not to mention technological advances and geopolitical context. In an ever-changing world, authority, experience, and expertise are not enough. Effective leaders must take an adaptive approach to navigate the complexities of conditions they don’t control and can’t always predict.

I learned something about navigating conditions beyond my control when I took sailing lessons on the San Francisco Bay. When I got to the dock for my first lesson, I had watched the instructional video and passed a written test. I could name the parts of the boat and points of sail and I had practiced tying knots – I was ready. My instructor Noah, an experienced sailor who had done multiple ocean crossings but was barely older than my own kids, told me, “Sailing is going from point A to point B across the water using the wind, a force we cannot control or see.” This was the first sign that my class would be about more than sailing. Instead, it was a hands-on experience that made tangible a number of leadership lessons and provided a powerful metaphor for leaders navigating in these complex times.

Lesson 1: Change Your Perspective. The sky was clearing and I felt a light breeze on my face as we motored out of the harbor, watching Giants stadium fall away behind us and Twin Peaks rise in the distance. The skyline of high-rises gleamed and huddled together, at once more beautiful and smaller in scale than they look from the street. This experience of changing my perspective highlighted the importance for leaders in a time of complexity to adopt multiple perspectives when tackling challenges, setting strategy, and working with others. If you are stuck in binary thinking, shifting perspective can help identify alternatives; or if you are in a situation that seems negative, you can seek the “silver lining”—look for opportunities within a challenge and find a constructive perspective for yourself and your team. Such reframing can help boost your own and others’ morale and motivation.

Lesson 2: Harness Forces You Don’t Control. Once we were out on open water, we got to work, hoisting the sails and pointing the nose of the boat on a “close haul” which is as close as you can get to pointing directly into the wind. Although people often talk about how great it is to have a tailwind, it turns out that when the wind is behind you, you can never go faster than the wind, but when you are at an angle to the wind (it’s physics—the sail is like the wing of a plane generating lift!), you can actually go faster than the speed of the wind. Mind blown! With close observation and skill, you can benefit from elements that you don’t control and that may even seem against you. The COVID pandemic was beyond any leaders’ control and forced business leaders and workers to change their ways of working. While many businesses suffered, some who were quick to adapt their ways of working were able to accelerate and succeed.

Leadership Lesson 3: Always Be Learning. As we got further out onto the bay, the current created by the ebbing tide (another force we did not control) worked against us as we tried to sail south, and we made little headway. I was frustrated , as it felt as if we were working hard and getting nowhere. If only the wind would pick up or the tide would turn! The whole thing started to feel like a bust. But Noah suggested that we use this relative calm to learn about the tides, adjust our course and use this opportunity to practice tacking—turning the boat through the wind to change direction and catch the wind on the other face of the sail. This allowed me to practice handling the helm (steering) and the main (sail). Whether it is taking time to learn from a failure or finding opportunities to practice new skills or behaviors on the job, keep learning.

Leadership Lesson 4: Pause Before Reacting. On the second day of my class, the sun was shining and all seemed in our favor, but then the wind died. The sail was slack and we bobbed on the blue surface of the water. My philosophical instructor, whom I learned was also a singer-songwriter, smiled as he shared a key lesson of both sailing and leadership: don’t overreact to a sudden change. Noah had been crossing the ocean when an old salt he was sailing with taught him that if the wind changed when he was on night watch, instead of waking his crew immediately to help raise or lower the sail, he should pause, make a cup of tea, drink it, and then decide what to do. Sometimes the wind would have shifted back, making it unnecessary to wake the crew. While quick action is sometimes called for, over-reaction to a change can cause a team to thrash. Before deciding the nature and extent of response, “have a cup of tea on it.”

Whether you are sailing along with the favorable winds of strong market conditions and smooth operations, being buffeted by high seas of competition, experiencing the shifting winds of change, or bobbing safely in harbor, you your choices about how you view and engage with conditions can help you steer your team or your organization toward success.

*I previously shared these ideas in radio essay format on KQED Perspective.